5 Must-Try Desserts in the Kansas City Area
A Sweet Side of Kansas City
Buying or selling a home is exciting, and sometimes you just need dessert.
If you know me, you know I love highlighting local gems around Kansas City. This city isn’t just about houses and neighborhoods; it’s about the culture, the food, and the experiences that make it feel like home. Whether you’re celebrating a closing or exploring your next neighborhood, here are five dessert stops around KC worth visiting.
1. Betty Rae’s Ice Cream
📍 7140 Wornall Rd, Kansas City, MO 64114
🍦 Best for: Creative flavors and casual fun
Betty Rae’s is a Kansas City favorite that always feels like summer. Known for bold and seasonal flavors like lavender honey, brown butter caramel, and goat cheese cherry, this local spot makes every scoop an adventure.
Pro Tip: Try a flight to sample a few flavors.
2. Blackhole Bakery
📍 5536 Troost Ave, Kansas City, MO 64110
🍩 Best for: Inventive pastries and weekend indulgence
Blackhole Bakery is one of those KC spots everyone talks about for good reason. Their Cosmic Brownie has become a local legend, and their croissants and mochi muffins sell out fast. The vibe is modern, relaxed, and full of energy.
Pro Tip: Go early on weekends — they often sell out before noon.
3. Andre’s Confiserie Suisse
📍 5018 Main St, Kansas City, MO 64112
🍫 Best for: Elegant chocolates and classic European pastries
Andre’s is timeless. Family-owned since 1955, this South Plaza favorite brings a little Swiss perfection to Kansas City. Their chocolate tortes, coconut macaroons, and truffles make any occasion feel special — from closing day to anniversary gifts.
Pro Tip: Pick up a box of assorted chocolates for a client or housewarming gift.
4. McLain’s Bakery + Market
📍 201 E Gregory Blvd, Kansas City, MO 64114
🍰 Best for: Family-friendly treats and KC tradition
McLain’s is one of Kansas City’s most beloved bakeries. It’s been part of the community for decades and still delivers that perfect mix of nostalgia and quality. Whether you stop in for a coffee, a cookie, or one of their iced cakes, McLain’s always feels like home.
Pro Tip: Grab their iced sugar cookies — they’re a KC classic.
5. Sylas and Maddy’s Homemade Ice Cream
📍 11925 S Strang Line Rd, Olathe, KS 66062
🍨 Best for: Homemade flavors and local charm
If you’re exploring homes in Johnson County, this is the perfect pit stop. Sylas and Maddy’s has that small-town energy and big-flavor creativity. Every batch is made in-house, and the rotating flavors keep locals coming back.
Pro Tip: Their Butter Brickle and Raspberry Cheesecake are can’t-miss favorites.
Wrapping It Up
Kansas City has a dessert for every mood, from upscale indulgence to nostalgic simplicity. These are the spots that make the metro feel like home, and that’s what I love about this city.
So whether you’re exploring neighborhoods, closing on your dream home, or just in need of something sweet, you now know where to go.
📞 Call or text: (785) 766-5087
📧 Email: jared@jareddunn.com
🌐 Visit: jareddunn.com
Because great homes deserve great desserts.